23 February, 2024

How Jimmy Finkelstein Wooed Me to The Messenger—And Left Me High and Dry

https://www.vanityfair.com/news/amie-parnes-jimmy-finkelstein-the-messenger

I spent weeks agonizing about it. I talked to colleagues and friends who said I almost had to take the job. After all, I knew the owner, and he had never let me fail. I had hours-long conversations with my parents. I talked to Bob who emphasized the durability and steadiness of my current job.

But mostly, I talked to Jimmy.

“As a single mom, I have no net,” I emphasized on each call with him to the point where even I was tired of hearing it. “If this fails, I have nothing to fall back on.”

During some of those calls, I remember pacing the room, on the outlines of my rug, as if I had been walking an actual tightrope. He was reassuring and had the confidence of a man who never had to worry about the balance in his checking account.

“You will be fine,” he told me again and again. “I will make sure of it.”

When I was having those conversations with Jimmy, I never once thought that the site would implode more than eight months later.

But here we are, and obviously, I am not fine. Neither are the nearly 300 colleagues of mine who lost their jobs in the most cruel and inhumane way imaginable, without warning and without a day of severance. Typically, employers offer COBRA, as a way of keeping your insurance for many months after termination, but ours will be pulled at the end of this month.

Future employers don’t readily have access to our work because the site has been shut down.

For me, it has been the ultimate betrayal.

A Marketplace of Girl Influencers Managed by Moms and Stalked by Men

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/02/22/us/instagram-child-influencers.html

Thousands of accounts examined by The Times offer disturbing insights into how social media is reshaping childhood, especially for girls, with direct parental encouragement and involvement. Some parents are the driving force behind the sale of photos, exclusive chat sessions and even the girls’ worn leotards and cheer outfits to mostly unknown followers. The most devoted customers spend thousands of dollars nurturing the underage relationships.

The large audiences boosted by men can benefit the families, The Times found. The bigger followings look impressive to brands and bolster chances of getting discounts, products and other financial incentives, and the accounts themselves are rewarded by Instagram’s algorithm with greater visibility on the platform, which in turn attracts more followers.

21 February, 2024

How Google is killing independent sites like ours

https://housefresh.com/david-vs-digital-goliaths/

HouseFresh has published over 60 hands-on reviews that were written on the basis of multiple performance tests. 

We can tell you that testing and reviewing products takes a lot of time, money, and effort. 

But if our small team can publish real reviews, then these big publishers and private equity surely have the resources to do the same. 

Unfortunately, right now, these companies are using all their resources to publish more and more pages peppered with the right ‘ingredients’ to dish up a tasty E-E-A-T meal for Google.

We have no doubt that these big publications could build their own labs, where they could run actual tests in order to make product recommendations backed by actual firsthand data. 

CNET bought an entire smart home back in 2015 in order to test products. That was before they were acquired by Red Ventures and found themselves selling the house after reporters told The Verge they were feeling pressured to change their reviews to be more favorable to brands that were being advertised on CNET. 

How many other ‘parent companies’ are using commerce or shopping editors to pass off promotional articles as editorial content?

Jon Stewart Is Back to Weigh In (2020)

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/06/15/magazine/jon-stewart-interview.html

It’s like the Levittown thing with Bill O’Reilly. He talks all about Levittown: ‘‘That’s where I learned my values. Bootstrapping it. I grew up in Levittown, and we learned that work does it.’’ Well, guess what? The deed to the properties said you were not allowed to sell them to a black person. (The standard leases, which included an option to buy, for the first houses built by Levitt & Sons in the late 1940s for the Long Island community soon to be called Levittown included a clause barring the houses from being sold to or occupied by nonwhites. The clause was dropped in 1948, but the racial dynamics remained.)

 Racism is built into this system. But not all the people in it are malevolent and active racists. There is an inert racism that exists, and it’s pernicious, but I don’t believe everybody who’s part of it is evil. So it’s more a question of trying to remove a right-left axis from the conversation and instead create a conversation around conditions. Poverty is poverty. The right will talk about poverty a certain way, and the left will talk about poverty a different way, but poor people are still poor people. They’re still without political power. 

15 February, 2024

The Day I Put $50,000 in a Shoe Box and Handed It to a Stranger

https://www.thecut.com/article/amazon-scam-call-ftc-arrest-warrants.html

The man on the phone knew my home address, my Social Security number, the names of my family members, and that my 2-year-old son was playing in our living room. He told me my home was being watched, my laptop had been hacked, and we were in imminent danger. “I can help you, but only if you cooperate,” he said. His first orders: I could not tell anyone about our conversation, not even my spouse, or talk to the police or a lawyer.

Now I know this was all a scam — a cruel and violating one but painfully obvious in retrospect. Here’s what I can’t figure out: Why didn’t I just hang up and call 911? Why didn’t I text my husband, or my brother (a lawyer), or my best friend (also a lawyer), or my parents, or one of the many other people who would have helped me? Why did I hand over all that money — the contents of my savings account, strictly for emergencies — without a bigger fight?

14 February, 2024

Let Me Tell You A Secret

https://blog.glyph.im/2024/02/let-me-tell-you-a-secret.html

So the intended audience for this piece is potential clients, leaders of teams (or organizations, or companies) who have a general technology problem and are wondering if they need a consultant with my skill-set to help them fix it. Before you decide that your issue is the need to implement a complex distributed system consensus algorithm, check if that is really what’s at issue. Talk to your ICs, and — taking care to make sure they understand that you want honest feedback and that they are safe to offer it — ask them what problems your organization has.

During this meeting it is important to only listen. Especially if you’re at a small company and you are regularly involved in the day-to-day operations, you might feel immediately defensive. Sit with that feeling, and process it later. Don’t unload your emotional state on an employee you have power over.

“Only listening” doesn’t exclusively mean “don’t push back”. You also shouldn’t be committing to fixing anything. While the information you are gathering in these meetings is extremely valuable, and you should probably act on more of it than you will initially want to, your ICs won’t have the full picture. They really may not understand why certain priorities are set the way they are. You’ll need to take that as feedback for improving internal comms rather than “fixing” the perceived problem, and you certainly don’t want to make empty promises.

13 February, 2024

The media's circular logic and destructive obsession with Biden's age

https://margaretsullivan.substack.com/p/the-medias-circular-logic-and-destructive

Biden’s advanced age is, granted, far from ideal for a president seeking a second term, even the very effective president that he has been. Yes, he’s old; and, never a gifted public speaker, he makes cringe-inducing mistakes. It would be great if he were 20 years younger. His age really is a legitimate concern for many voters.

But for the media to make this the overarching issue of the campaign is nothing short of journalistic malpractice.

That’s especially the case when Trump is poised to take down American democracy, starting on Day One, and when he has been criminally charged 91 times in multiple states, including for trying to overturn the legitimate 2020 election. Also, he’s old and gaffe-prone himself.

Much more alarmingly, this very weekend, Trump was out there threatening to abandon our NATO allies and let Russia “do whatever the hell they want.” Appropriately, that story was leading major news sites by Sunday afternoon, but, in a week, count the news stories and commentary pieces on that versus those involving Biden’s age.

I think we all know the winner.

Is there no one at these major outlets who is capable of taking a step back and exercising some judgment?

12 February, 2024

Biden moving closer than ever to a breach with Netanyahu over war in Gaza

https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2024/02/11/biden-netanyahu-closer-to-a-breach/

White House officials have increasingly concluded that Netanyahu is focused on his own political survival to the exclusion of any other goal, and is eager to position himself as standing up to Biden’s push for a two-state solution. During a news conference last month, Netanyahu publicly rebuked Biden over his support for a Palestinian state, saying an Israeli prime minister needs to be “capable of saying no to our friends.”

“Netanyahu is playing to his politics at home, and if he thinks it helps him to trash Biden publicly, he’ll do it,” said Frank Lowenstein, a former State Department official who helped lead Israeli-Palestinian negotiations in 2014.

One of the biggest reasons Biden has not been quicker to criticize Netanyahu, aides say, is his decades-long relationship with the prime minister. Biden often says he tells Netanyahu, “I love you, Bibi, even if I can’t stand you.”

Netanyahu has at times helped reinforce Biden’s view of Israel as a heroic bulwark against global antisemitism. During one visit when Biden was vice president, Netanyahu showed him photos of grossly antisemitic depictions that came from Hamas and argued such incitement was the reason he could not make peace with the Palestinians, according to a person familiar with the interaction, speaking on the condition of anonymity to describe a private exchange.

Grammys Winners

https://billychilds.bandcamp.com/album/the-winds-of-change

https://blindboysofalabama.bandcamp.com/album/echoes-of-the-south

Hailed as "gospel titans" by Rolling Stone, the Blind Boys of Alabama defied the considerable odds stacked against them in the segregated South, working their way up from singing for pocket change to performing for three different presidents over the course of an 80-year career that saw them break down racial barriers, soundtrack the Civil Rights movement, and help redefine modern gospel music forever. The five-time Grammy-winners’ latest album, Echoes Of The South, draws its name from the Birmingham radio program that hosted the group’s very first professional performance back in 1944.

Kirk Franklin - All Things


Lil Durk - All My Life ft. J. Cole (Official Video)


For the Birds: The Birdsong Project is a collection of 172 pieces of new music inspired by the beauty of birdsong, performed by artists from across the musical spectrum. 

The Peacemaker

http://media2.sbhla.org.s3.amazonaws.com/missionjournals/hm/hm_1972_12.pdf

Peace has one thing in common with its enemy, with the fiend it battles, with war.

Peace is active, not passive.
Peace is doing, not waiting.
Peace is aggressive—attacking.
Peace plans its strategy and encircles the enemy.
Peace marshals its forces and storms the gates.
Peace gathers its weapons and pierces the defense.

Peace, like war, is waged.

The weapons of peace are love, joy, goodness. longsuffering
The arms of peace are justice, truth, patience, prayer.
The strategy of peace brings safety, welfare. happiness
The forces of peace are the children of God. 
Yes. Christ has turned it all around: I am to love my enemy

11 February, 2024

Kyed: Remembering Hallie and covering the Patriots through unimaginable circumstances

https://www.bostonherald.com/2024/02/11/kyed-remembering-hallie-and-covering-the-patriots-through-unimaginable-circumstances/

If there’s one thing I want you to know about Hallie, it’s that she never stopped fighting.

My daughter, Hallie James Kyed, died on Jan. 21 of acute myeloid leukemia. She was 2 years old — just two months shy of her third birthday.

One day before she passed away at Boston Children’s Hospital, Hallie gave us a gift. Her counts, which had been precipitously declining, improved. Her white blood cell counts had dropped. The percentage of leukemia blasts in her blood had fallen. Her electrolyte levels had settled. Hallie’s team of doctors – among the best in the world at what they do – couldn’t fully explain why it was happening, but they also didn’t want to give us false hope. We had already been told in the previous week and thereafter in no uncertain terms that Hallie was not going to make it. 

10 February, 2024

The Mount Pleasant Miracle

https://www.washingtonpost.com/magazine/2021/01/25/mount-pleasant-washington-dc-gentrification/

In recent decades, a tide of gentrification has swept across America’s urban centers. In Washington, office blocks have sprung up along North and South Capitol streets, while whole new neighborhoods have been created around previously underused real estate: Union Market in a Northeast warehouse district, Nationals Park on the Anacostia River waterfront. And some communities have all but vanished: From 1980 to 2010, Shaw went from being 80 percent Black to 30 percent.

Mount Pleasant, meanwhile, has followed an unusual trajectory: It hasn’t changed much at all. It has long been a haven for immigrants, activists, punk rockers, entrepreneurs, revolutionaries and returning Peace Corps volunteers — and it still is. The residential streets sloping down to Rock Creek Park are thick with do-gooders: social workers, wonks, economists, immigration lawyers, musicians, ministers, artists, florists, yoga instructors, divorce lawyers and even the odd journalist. The apartment buildings along Mount Pleasant Street are more diverse: home to busboys, cooks, cashiers, waitresses, teachers, security guards and esquineros (corner guys), the older Latin men who drink coffee and play dominoes outside the paint store.

08 February, 2024

Marking the Moment: Coding It Forward’s Leadership Transition

https://blog.codingitforward.com/marking-the-moment-coding-it-forwards-leadership-transition-f254ce8a0b7d

We cannot tell the story of Coding It Forward without telling the story of Rachel and Ariana’s involvement to date. We are tremendously lucky as an organization to have two such talented leaders on the team, with the opportunity to transition seamlessly between them.

After serving in the inaugural cohort of Fellows at the U.S. Census Bureau, Rachel became Coding It Forward’s first (and only) full-time employee from her graduation in 2018 until the staff grew in 2020. She has dedicated the past 7 years to building Coding It Forward in ways large and small, and as such, her impact on the organization is nearly impossible to quantify. During her tenure, Coding It Forward grew from its dorm room roots into an established, national public interest tech organization. We are so very grateful to her for her tireless contributions, thoughtful leadership, and for all that she has done to set the organization up for stability and scale. We cannot wait to witness her next chapter.

Speaking of next chapters, Coding It Forward’s future is exceedingly bright under the leadership of incoming CEO Ariana.

Ariana, too, has been a part of Coding It Forward’s founding team from her student days, beginning her work with Coding It Forward years ago while still a sophomore in college. As Deputy Director, Ariana has been a fierce and eloquent champion for the mission, a source of empathy and expertise as the primary face of Coding It Forward to government partners on the ground, and a key driver of Coding It Forward’s expansion into an offering for state and local governments in addition to federal. It is hard to leave a conversation with Ariana not feeling inspired into action. We are all so excited for her tenure.

Fast Car at the Grammys - Tracy Chapman, Luke Combs

https://www.grammy.com/videos/tracy-chapman-luke-combs-fast-car-2024-grammys-performance-66th-annual-grammy-awards?streamUrl=https://nomad-content.grammy.com/pmc/2f/6d/c5/2f6dc584-337d-4a9e-8b03-916f21017e49/tra-apple-hls-acc/0312-cbsperf2-gmypgmbug-tp.m3u8&title=Tracy%20Chapman%20and%20Luke%20Combs%20Perform%20%E2%80%9CFast%20Car%E2%80%9D%20%7C%202024%20GRAMMYs



07 February, 2024

Why You’ve Never Been In A Plane Crash

https://asteriskmag.com/issues/05/why-you-ve-never-been-in-a-plane-crash

Sometimes disasters happen anyway, and when they do, it’s equally critical that the just culture is upheld. Although it can be hard to accept that a mistake that led to loss of life might go unpunished, just culture doesn’t permit us to discriminate based on the magnitude of the consequences — only on the attitude of the person who committed the error. If they were acting in good faith when the mistake occurred, then a harsh reaction would undermine the trust between employees and management that facilitates the just culture. But even more importantly, it would undermine the blameless investigative process that makes modern aviation so safe. Investigative agencies like the NTSB rely on truthful statements from those involved in an accident in order to determine what happened and why, and the truth can’t be acquired when individuals fear punishment for speaking it. Indeed, if Wascher were charged with a crime, her lawyers would have been required to produce a defense, and the investigative waters would have been forever clouded.


05 February, 2024

Apple Vision Pro review: magic, until it’s not

https://www.theverge.com/24054862/apple-vision-pro-review-vr-ar-headset-features-price

The Apple Vision Pro is the best consumer headset anyone’s ever made — and that’s the problem.

 

My Self-Publishing Journey & Lessons Learned (73 Page Slide Deck)

https://pathlesspath.com/selfpublishinglessons/

If you want to read my step-by-step journey of how I self-published my book, you can read my 8,000-word post explaining every step of the process.

But if you want a more fun PowerPoint-based story (only something a former strategy consultant would ever say), you can check out the deck I put together below.

Tracy Chapman Earns Rapturous Standing Ovation After Rare Live Performance of ‘Fast Car’ With Luke Combs

https://variety.com/2024/music/news/tracy-chapman-luke-combs-duet-performance-2024-grammys-fast-car-1235894485/

Tracy Chapman always knew she “could be someone.” But could the folk singer have predicted in 1988, the year she released “Fast Car,” that she would perform her now-iconic song alongside country artist Luke Combs at the 66th Grammy Awards?

The two singers, though hailing from different generations and musical genres, took the stage together on Feb. 4 for a duet rendition of the song that has generated massive success for both of them. Decades after its initial release, “Fast Car” re-entered the charts when Combs’ cover of the track, infused with a country sensibility, became immensely popular in 2023.

Dressed all in black, Chapman kicked off her performance at the Grammys playing the iconic first few bars on her guitar, sparking voracious cheers from the star-studded audience which included Kacey Musgraves, Taylor Swift and Kelly Clarkson. Chapman and Combs bounced back and forth sharing the spotlight and but sang together in beautiful harmony for the chorus. After they finished, the crowd leapt to their feet in a thunderous applause. 

04 February, 2024

Georgia Baptists sell old headquarters at a big loss

https://www.timesfreepress.com/news/2024/jan/18/georga-baptists-sell-old-headquarters-at-a-big/

After seeking a buyer for years, the donor-funded Georgia Baptist Mission Board has sold its former Duluth headquarters (6405 Sugarloaf Pkwy) for about half what the organization originally paid for the land and building.

The $23.5 million sale, reported early this month by the convention's newspaper, stands in contrast to the $43.5 million the mission board has said it spent on the property, where it built the stately building in 2006.

Noted — and sometimes critiqued — for its grandeur, the five-story building sits on a roughly 40-acre plot on Duluth's Sugarloaf Parkway, across from the county sports and convention center, Gwinnett County property records show.

Georgia Baptists eliminate retiree benefits, citing budget concerns (2021)

https://baptistnews.com/article/georgia-baptists-eliminate-retiree-benefits-citing-budget-concerns/#.YrJsCezMKDE

Phil Pilgrim, a recent retiree, served as a Georgia pastor, convention vice president, member of both the Nominating Committee and Executive Committee, and state missionary. He says the retiree cuts are unprecedented nationally and fears it could set a precedent for other states to follow Georgia’s lead.

“It seems that the board now sees retirees as an old candy bar,” he said. “They have used people in the prime of their lives and have eaten out the good center and thrown away the wrapper. They see no moral, ethical or spiritual problem in breaking promises made to retirees simply because, they rationalize, they did not make those commitments.”

Pilgrim sees many biblical comparisons between what has happened to women like Willis in music ministries being single and Newman, as a widow.


Hubris

https://www.smallwood-us.com/work/case-study/arch-georgia-baptist-convention-headquarters-office

The Georgia Baptist Convention (now Mission Board) was located in a conventional office building environment, with the various missions located in separate office suites with no relation to one another. The project was seen as an opportunity to forge a new sense of shared purpose among groups which had traditionally pursued their goals with little or no coordination. To help realize the vision of this alliance of independent ministries, Smallwood led focus group discussions which allowed everyone in the organization to have input on the environment, technology, and culture of the new facility. This process confirmed the desire for closer collaboration and a sense of greater community among the various ministry groups. In response, a shared public level includes a formal reception area, a pre-function space leading to the tiered chapel/meeting room and multipurpose meeting room, and an exhibit on the history of the Convention. 


01 February, 2024

Disinfo and Elections in the Global Majority

https://ethanzuckerman.com/2023/12/02/disinfo-and-elections-in-the-global-majority/

These narratives emerge online, from hired guns and from individual partisans. The language for the narratives online differs between countries. Brazil has firm policies, set by the electoral court, allowing them to order removal of disinformation, and so that’s the term of choice in the Brazilian context. Jonathan and team see the problem as broader than disinformation, including different forms of propaganda, and refer to this online speech as “influence operations”. I like this term, as it includes a particularly tricky type of speech: participatory propaganda, where partisans spread and shape narratives on their own, not necessarily because they are receiving commands as part of a “cyber army”.


What I wish someone had told me about starting a meditation practice

https://sashachapin.substack.com/p/what-i-wish-someone-had-told-me-about

Here is a better set of beginner meditation instructions: “Settle in a posture that, for you, provides a good compromise between comfort and alertness. Open yourself to the detail of your experience. Allow yourself to be interested in, and receptive to, the rich, particular texture of what’s happening—look beyond the concept of experience into what’s actually going on with your mind, and senses, and emotions. Don’t argue with what’s there. If you wish, bring your attention to a meditation object, like a mantra, or the flow of your breath, and notice how this tends to make your experience more collected and calmer. Orient towards whatever brings relief, wakeful relaxation, and pleasantness. Do this for anywhere between thirty seconds and ninety minutes.”


31 January, 2024

How to be less neurotic about getting back to people

https://sashachapin.substack.com/p/how-to-be-less-neurotic-about-getting


Remember that your primary job is being responsive

When you get an email from someone, you are, on the surface, being asked to accomplish some task, like schedule a meeting, or provide advice. But, fundamentally , you are being recruited to mitigate the nightmarish loneliness that plagues us all. Thankfully, any halfway coherent response accomplishes this job. You have acknowledged their existence: excellent! It can be extremely clarifying to look at this as the primary goal of communication, rather than, say, imposing your wit, or nullifying the possibility of conflict. Moreover, if this is seen as the goal, it might imply that you should put in less effort—a long, studied reply might be seen more as an attempt to impress, rather than a reciprocated connection.

How hard is it to cheat with ChatGPT in technical interviews? We ran an experiment.

https://interviewing.io/blog/how-hard-is-it-to-cheat-with-chatgpt-in-technical-interviews

As it turns out, not a single interviewer mentioned concerns about any of the candidates cheating!

We were stunned to discover that interviewers reported no suspicions of cheating, and interestingly, interviewees were largely confident that they were getting away with it, too. 81% reported no concerns about being caught, 13% thought they might have tipped off the interviewer, and an astonishingly small 6% of participants thought the interviewer suspected them of cheating.

The candidates who worried they were caught did have abnormal comments from the interviewers in the post-survey analysis, but they still were not suspected of cheating. To summarize, most candidates thought they were getting away with cheating — and they were right!

Jobs Americans Would Do

https://americancompass.org/jobs-americans-would-do/

The celebration is not forthcoming. For all its talk about productivity, the business community’s enthusiasm for price signals and efficient market outcomes turns out to be rather selective. The implication of Bernie’s thinking is a second answer: that some jobs are better than others and should pay more. The programmer could pick lettuce if he wanted, but the farmworker cannot code. Past market outcomes were so readily celebrated because they reinforced this worldview. The phrase “jobs Americans won’t do” is so potent because, in setting out certain classes of work as beneath the dignity of the people issuing the judgment, it makes clear exactly what they really think. The irony is that, to maintain his faith that wages fairly reflect productivity, and advance his preference for a supply of low-wage labor that eases his own life and elevates his own status, the “free market” enthusiast must embrace the role of central planner overriding price signals with his own judgment of what prices should be.

 

A Visual Book Summary of Atomic Habits by James Clear

https://www.thunknotes.com/blog/a-visual-book-summary-of-atomic-habits-by-james-clear

Winners and losers have the same goals

What we really need is something that makes success inevitable.

Imagine two people trying to start a weekly newsletter. 

Person A writes down their goal, but they’re overwhelmed and don’t know where to start, so they don’t take action towards achieving it. Person B focuses on the steps to achieve their goal. They create a system:

  • Write every morning at 8 AM for 30 minutes
  • Edit on Thursdays at 6 PM
  • Schedule the email to go out on Monday at 10 AM.

Which person is more likely to start a newsletter?

We don't need better goals. We need better systems.


Why Christians Have a Hard Time Believing it’s Actually Wrong to Abuse Someone, as Long as Another Christian Does It: Part 1

https://laurarbnsn.substack.com/p/why-christians-have-a-hard-time-believing

There are a few beliefs that make Christians in particular subcultures vulnerable to believing abuse, particularly against women and children, is actually not that serious as long as it is done by another Christian. They are:
  1. Hierarchy is Health. Good relationships are about knowing and occupying your assigned spot based on age and gender. Most social problems are caused by people failing to comply with their assigned rank. Relationships where rank and role are honored are healthier. Relationships where they aren’t are worse. In general, it’s more desirable to err on the side of a relationship being more hierarchical, not less, since hierarchy is itself an agent of good and order.
  2. There Is No Trauma, Only Sin. Depression, mental illness, and damage are manifestations of sin and the individual’s bad habits. They need to be repented of. They have no more power than people give them. Trauma and mental illness can be set aside like any bad habit.
  3. People Like That Are the Only People Here. As a result of the conversion experience and the Holy Spirit, Christians are a class of people whose behavior is rational, consciously motivated, and comprehensible to everyone. Christians make mistakes but are fundamentally trustworthy. Serious wrongdoing is usually caused by some kind of external agent, usually addiction or demonic forces. This state of being affected by the external agent is temporary and easy to resolve. Only outside the church are people likely to be recklessly and chaotically dangerous.

Two former CIA officials spoke to Insider before the 20th anniversary of the US invasion of Iraq.

https://www.businessinsider.com/george-bush-liar-cia-mohammed-atta-prague-911-iraq-invasion-2023-3

Alice: A lot of that pressure on the agency comes down through the briefers. They come back from their meetings with the president and other senior officials, give feedback. On a contentious issue you might go to a meeting upstairs on the seventh floor, with the briefers, where everybody is in the room. Once, I was writing a PDB [item for the President's Daily Brief] on what going into Iraq would likely do to our terrorism cooperation with allies. The message I got back was, the president doesn't want to hear about this. Iraq was a done deal.

Bob: They were all saying that. I mean, the US was moving our forces over to the Middle East big-time. You're not going to waste all that fuel and transport power and then listen to Saddam. British intelligence realized it first. They essentially said, "My god, these people are going to invade. It doesn't matter what we write. It doesn't matter what their own intelligence analysts tell them about the consequences. They're going to invade."

Alice: I remember just totally blocking this whole thing out of my mind. I was like, "No we can't possibly go into Iraq because that would be the worst thing we could possibly do." And then one day, I realized we were going. It was a done deal. It was a horrible thing. Because we had a real opportunity to deal a death blow to al-Qaeda, or at least get it down to a level where it would be manageable. Instead we blew it up. We created the conditions that led to the rise of ISIS.

Lessons learned from my time at the CFPB

http://radar.oreilly.com/2014/01/lessons-learned-from-my-time-at-the-cfpb.html#more-58926

There is a cost to keeping an agency digitally illiterate. But there is also a cost to reshaping a bureaucracy to do something new. Every time something new becomes a priority, a pre-existing operation, tool, team, or process — one that the organization doesn’t know how to live without — must end. That has consequences. It creates inefficiency. It confuses staff. It increases the risk that money will go missing or that data will be compromised. Why would a federal leader embrace these risks so that their successor can reap the benefits years later?


Pope Francis Defends Restrictions on Tridentine Mass

https://spectator.org/pope-francis-defends-restrictions-on-tridentine-mass/
Francis explained that this so-called disease of indietrismo is why he has restricted the celebration of the Tridentine Mass.

“After all the necessary consultations, I decided this because I saw that the good pastoral measures put in place by [Popes] John Paul II and Benedict XVI were being used in an ideological way, to go backward,” he said.

It is sadly true that there are some whose devotion to the Tridentine Mass is an ideological one: they reject the Second Vatican Council, they reject Pope Francis, and some even reject all popes since Pius XII, who died in 1958. Such devotees effectively choose a particular form of the liturgy — admittedly, a breathtakingly beautiful form of the liturgy, one long held in the highest of esteem — over unity with the Catholic Church, making them schismatic. 

A Technologist Walks Into the US Government

https://ssir.org/articles/entry/a_technologist_walks_into_the_us_government 

Help technologists stay in public interest technology. Many PIT recruiting initiatives often fail to create an environment that encourages technologists to stay long term (many go back to the private sector). In my own experience, technologists have left due to a lack of good management (which can be hard to come by in government), a lack of upward mobility due to career paths being unclear, a lack of opportunities to further sharpen their tech skills, and a lack of community. We should invest in educational opportunities for PITs to easily grow into their management and technical skills, and consider funding rotational programs for PITs to learn different ways their technology skills can be useful in government. We must also create community-building opportunities that encourage mid-career peers to network, share new opportunities in the public interest space, and offer access to late-career mentors.

Boards Are Broken, So Let’s Break and Remake Them


A small, not entirely complete list of the problems with boards:
  • Boards are filled with people who have little or no expertise in the mission or the product of the organization.
  • Boards gather only a handful of hours a quarter and usually don’t have enough time to do the things they say they will do.
  • Boards give themselves ultimate decision-making power to determine the organization’s finances, policies, and future.
  • Boards demand that we engage them, creating essentially another “program” for the staff to manage.
  • Most boards do not reflect the communities we are trying to serve.
  • Boards have no one to be accountable to.
  • Boards decide who gets to be in their clubs.

The Institutionalist's Dilemma

https://theap.substack.com/p/the-institutionalists-dilemma?s=r

One of the more consequential contradictions of the Democratic Party is that the vast majority of its staffers, consultants, electeds, and media avatars, along with a substantial portion of its electoral base, are institutionalists. They believe, broadly, in The System. The System worked for them, and if The System’s outputs are bad, it is because we need more of the right sort of people to join or be elected to enter The System. But when the party does manage to win majorities, it depends on support from a substantial number of anti-system people. Barack Obama defeated the Clintons with this sacred knowledge, before he started reading David Brooks.

Institutionalists, in my experience, have trouble reaching an anti-system person, because they think being against The System is an inherently adolescent and silly mindset. But believing in things like “the integrity of the Supreme Court” has proven to be, I think, much sillier, and much more childish.

In the beginning of Joe Biden’s presidency a lot of very intelligent people tried to come up with ideas for how to change the Supreme Court, which is poised to spend years eroding the regulatory state and chipping away at civil rights. Expand it, perhaps. Or marginalize it. President Joe Biden, a committed institutionalist, formed a commission of legal scholars—from across the ideological spectrum, of course—to investigate what ought to be done about it. They failed to come up with any answers. “Lawmakers,” the commission wrote, “should be cautious about any reform that seems aimed at the substance of Court decisions or grounded in interpretations of the Constitution over which there is great disagreement in our political life.” You might be mad at the Court because of the decisions it produces, but it’s essential that everyone still trusts the processes that led to them.

This was a white flag.

The Empty Chamber (2010)

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2010/08/09/the-empty-chamber

The weakened institution could no longer withstand pressures from outside its walls; as money and cameras rushed in, independent minds fell more and more in line with the partisans. Rough parity between the two parties meant that every election had the potential to make or break a majority, crushing the incentive to coöperate across the aisle. The Senate, no longer a fount of ideas, became a backwater of the U.S. government. During the Clinton years, the main action was between the White House and the Gingrich House of Representatives; during the Bush years, the Republican Senate majority abdicated the oversight role that could have placed a vital check on executive power.

Norman Ornstein, a congressional expert at the American Enterprise Institute, said that the Senate has increasingly become populated by “ideologues and charlatans.” He went on, “When we do get good people who come in, they very quickly get ground up by the dynamic and the culture of the parties. And once you get there, look at what it takes to stay there.” He spoke of Charles Grassley, the Iowa Republican, who, nearing the end of his career, spent much of last year working closely with his friend Max Baucus on the health-care bill. Then, in August, Grassley went home and, faced with angry Republican voters and the prospect of a primary challenge from the right, started warning about “pulling the plug on Grandma.” Ornstein added that similar pressures had led John McCain to begin “altering his behavior and abandoning every issue, including campaign-finance reform.”

Elizabeth Banks Thinks This Interview Is Dangerous for Her

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/09/26/magazine/elizabeth-banks-interview.html

One of my least favorite things to do in talking to people like you is to represent all women in Hollywood who are doing interesting things. I am in a rarefied category. There are very few female directors in Hollywood. There are even fewer who are actresses who have become directors. I’ve [expletive] worked my tail off to be able to do what I’m doing. I would love for you to interview the studio heads and the corporations and ask them these questions, because I can’t solve it. I’m putting my head down and showing these big corporations that if they give women the opportunity to do this job, they can make a good product that can make them a profit. It’s a male-dominated industry. It’s a male-dominated world. That’s what I’m up against, but I can’t solve it and I don’t really want to analyze it. It’s not interesting to me. It puts me, frankly, in a position where the studio head is going to read it in The New York Times and be like, “Wow, that Liz Banks has got a lot to say.” I don’t need that added pressure. I truly feel that it’s dangerous to talk about these things now...

....I’ve just been put in this position of my statements’ being perceived as being grand when they’re really just about my personal experience, which is all I should be talking about. I was told by a big producer of big action movies that I couldn’t direct action, that male actors were not going to follow me. He was flummoxed at the idea that a woman would be able to lead the Rock on a C.G.I. screen, I guess? That was said by someone with a lot of power in our industry to my face.

You should’ve asked

https://english.emmaclit.com/2017/05/20/you-shouldve-asked/

When a man expects his partner to ask him to do things, he's viewing her at the manager of the household chores. So its up to her to know what needs to be done and when. The problem with that is that planning and organizing things (the mental load) is already a full time job.

How Millennials Became The Burnout Generation

https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/annehelenpetersen/millennials-burnout-generation-debt-work

While writing this piece, I was orchestrating a move, planning travel, picking up prescriptions, walking my dog, trying to exercise, making dinner, attempting to participate in work conversations on Slack, posting photos to social media, and reading the news. I was waking up at 6 a.m. to write, packing boxes over lunch, moving piles of wood at dinner, falling into bed at 9. I was on the treadmill of the to-do list: one damn thing after another. But as I finish this piece, I feel something I haven’t felt in a long time: catharsis. I feel great. I feel something — which is not something I’ve really felt upon the completion of a task in some time.

There are still things to tackle after this. But for the first time, I’m seeing myself, the parameters of my labor, and the causes of my burnout clearly. And it doesn’t feel like the abyss. It doesn’t feel hopeless. It’s not a problem I can solve, but it’s a reality I can acknowledge, a paradigm through which I can understand my actions.

THE TRAUMA FLOOR - The secret lives of Facebook moderators in America

https://www.theverge.com/2019/2/25/18229714/cognizant-facebook-content-moderator-interviews-trauma-working-conditions-arizona

The moderators told me it’s a place where the conspiracy videos and memes that they see each day gradually lead them to embrace fringe views. One auditor walks the floor promoting the idea that the Earth is flat. A former employee told me he has begun to question certain aspects of the Holocaust. Another former employee, who told me he has mapped every escape route out of his house and sleeps with a gun at his side, said: “I no longer believe 9/11 was a terrorist attack.”

Chloe cries for a while in the break room, and then in the bathroom, but begins to worry that she is missing too much training. She had been frantic for a job when she applied, as a recent college graduate with no other immediate prospects. When she becomes a full-time moderator, Chloe will make $15 an hour — $4 more than the minimum wage in Arizona, where she lives, and better than she can expect from most retail jobs.

Pity Writing Studies, the Field That Hates Itself

https://freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/pity-writing-studies-the-field-that

Obscure research is one thing; a failure to support teaching is another. A truly toxic dynamic for our university system is that the conferences and journals and organizations are run by the tenured, but the tenured don’t teach low-level classes. In some writing programs at research universities tenured faculty don’t teach undergraduate writing at all. (I in fact know of several professors who had to go to great lengths within their institutions to be allowed to continue teaching basic or freshman writing.) Instead, freshman writing is dominantly taught by adjuncts and, at schools with graduate programs, grad students. Again, the actual brick-and-mortar work of teaching students how to write sentences, paragraphs, and papers is essential to the finances of programs that run writing classes but disdained by many of the faculty who are funded by such classes. But the work continues, and freshman writing is sometimes cited as the single most commonly-taught class in the American university system. The people who teach such classes are typically overworked and undertrained, and they could use better insights into the process. More than once at conferences I met adjunct instructors and professors at teaching colleges who ruefully pointed out that the large conference programs contained not a single presentation that would be of use to people looking to teach actual writing. But the tenured at research universities don’t teach those classes, and the contingent labor that does lacks the voice to induce change.


Yesterday I Was Levi’s Brand President. I Quit So I Could Be Free.

https://www.thefp.com/p/yesterday-i-was-levis-brand-president

Things changed when Covid hit. Early on in the pandemic, I publicly questioned whether schools had to be shut down. This didn’t seem at all controversial to me. I felt—and still do—that the draconian policies would cause the most harm to those least at risk, and the burden would fall heaviest on disadvantaged kids in public schools, who need the safety and routine of school the most.

I wrote op-eds, appeared on local news shows, attended meetings with the mayor’s office, organized rallies and pleaded on social media to get the schools open. I was condemned for speaking out. This time, I was called a racist—a strange accusation given that I have two black sons—a eugenicist, and a QAnon conspiracy theorist.

In the summer of 2020, I finally got the call. “You know when you speak, you speak on behalf of the company,” our head of corporate communications told me, urging me to pipe down. I responded: “My title is not in my Twitter bio. I’m speaking as a public school mom of four kids.”

But the calls kept coming. From legal. From HR. From a board member. And finally, from my boss, the CEO of the company. I explained why I felt so strongly about the issue, citing data on the safety of schools and the harms caused by virtual learning. While they didn’t try to muzzle me outright, I was told repeatedly to “think about what I was saying.”

Regulatory capture’s third face of power

https://academic.oup.com/ser/article/21/2/1217/7030814?login=false#407650172

The study of regulatory capture is thus the study of the third face of power. One of regulatory capture’s hallmarks is the appearance of consensus or a taken-for-granted quality in which certain social and economic facts resonating with dominant cultural schemas are made legible and commonsensical, while others are obscured. Policymakers consent to corporate policy agendas not through coercion or overt corruption, but through a process in which lobbyists embed themselves in policy networks and extend the ‘public interest’ to incorporate their own interests (Figure 4). While public officials initially had no agenda for grappling with data and digital trade at the start of the Obama Administration—and in fact were pursuing policies that would contradict the digital trade agenda—they came to understand digital trade as a natural extension of ‘normal’ trade policy and pursued a legal order for digital trade. As I show in this article, this legal order developed with technology lobbyists driving every step of the process, from initial policy adoptions to knowledge production, implementation and enforcement.


I.R.S. to Begin Trial of Its Own Free Tax-Filing System

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/05/your-money/irs-tax-filing-free-online.html

The Internal Revenue Service is rolling out a free option for filing federal tax returns this year to some residents of a dozen states.

Last month, the agency published details of its plan to test an in-house filing system, in which taxpayers submit their federal tax returns directly to the agency online at no cost. Residents of 12 states are eligible to participate if they meet certain criteria.

“This is a critical step forward for this innovative effort that will test the feasibility of providing taxpayers a new option to file their returns for free directly with the I.R.S.,” Danny Werfel, the agency’s commissioner, said in a recent statement.

While the direct filing system is starting on a limited basis, it has already faced some resistance, particularly from commercial tax-preparation companies.


The forecasting fallacy

https://www.alexmurrell.co.uk/articles/the-forecasting-fallacy

It’s time we opened our eyes.

Let’s stop clamouring over the ten-year trend decks. Let’s stop counting on the constant conjecture of consultants. Let’s stop trying to guess the future and start trying to build it.

We do not travel through time on a predefined path. The future is not fixed but the result of the actions we take in the present. If you want to be successful over the next 10 years, start building a competitive advantage over the next 10 months. If you want to win tomorrow, start tilting the table today. If you believe things should change in the future, put pen to paper in the present.

The future is uncertain. You cannot predict it. But you can create it.

Or as Cindy Gallup likes to say:
“In order to predict the future, you have to invent it".

Cheap and They Don't Snitch: Drones Are the New Drug Mules

https://www.vice.com/en/article/qjvma7/drug-trafficking-smugglers-using-drones

Last week border officials in the Punjab region of India revealed they intercepted 107 drug-carrying drones sent by smuggling gangs last year over the border from Pakistan, the highest number on record. [...]

In October last year the U.K. government was forced to introduce no fly zones around all its prisons due to a “sharp increase” in the number of drones carrying drugs and mobile phones into jails.


HOWTO: Change your behavior

https://matt.might.net/articles/how-to-change-your-behavior/

In theory, behavior change should be easy.

At first glance, it seems like you control your behavior.

So, if you desire different behavior, why doesn’t your behavior change as instantly as your desire to change it?

In short, lasting change of habitual behaviors is a multi-stage process.

In 1977, as psychologists James Prochaska and Carlo DiClemente were studying the behavior of smokers, they identified these stages.

Their transtheoretical model of behavior change captures the process of behavior change in six different phases: (1) precontemplation; (2) contemplation; (3) preparation; (4) action; (5) maintenance; and (6) relapse.

Risk-Aversion Is Killing Romance

https://www.freyaindia.co.uk/p/risk-aversion-is-killing-romance

It’s tragic, all of this. Tragic because it’s putting us on a trajectory to miss out on what’s actually meaningful. There’s no love without vulnerability. There’s no life without fear. And you will no doubt derail romance if you are too risk-averse. I’ve written elsewhere about how I think this fear of discomfort is in part why young people are putting off major life decisions like marriage and having children. What’s interesting to me about all these #childfree TikToks everyone likes to dunk on isn’t that people don’t want kids—I don’t think everyone should—it’s that they often don’t want them out of fear. Like that TikToker who created “The List”—a crowdsourced list of reasons not to have children that’s been seen by millions—which includes every possible risk from swollen ankles to rashes to bloating to muscle cramps. Really? We’re willing to miss out on the richest and most beautiful moments of being human—what actually makes life worth living—because it comes with risk?

The Rebirth of Russian Spycraft

https://www.foreignaffairs.com/russian-federation/rebirth-russian-spycraft

How the Ukraine War Has Changed the Game for the Kremlin’s Operatives—and Their Western Rivals


İyad el-Baghdadi on the West's standing

https://twitter.com/iyad_elbaghdadi/status/1608104106781974528

For years we've been talking about the "erosion" of the West's standing in the world as a result of the systemic betrayal of human rights, free speech & democracy on the world stage. Decision by decision, admin after admin, year after year

Erosion is gradual and slow-moving, and can be ignored. Sometimes we can doubt if it's even happening. Until we get a natural disaster that reminds us. 

I can't sleep


The propaganda kills me. People I thought were friends, were allies. So much humanity for those killed on October 7th, none for the people killed on the 8th, 9th, 10th, 11th, 12th, or in November or December [16]. 20,000 people, killed by deliberate, indiscriminate bombing [17].

None either for the people killed on Oct 6th, 5th, 4th [18]. For the people massacred in 1948 [19] and since. No protest of the illegal occupation [20], the illegal settlements [21]. The razing of the villages [22] and the olive groves [23]. They don't exist to them; they didn't happen.

Hi! I'm Alicia Johnson, LMFT a licensed therapist specializing in burnout and stress. Ask me anything!

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/18hniiw/hi_im_alicia_johnson_lmft_a_licensed_therapist/

You are correct that there is no formal diagnosis of burnout. in the mental health field we describe it as the complete emotional, mental, and physical exhaustion people face and the related symptoms that occur due to it.

People can recover from burnout by setting boundaries, living in line with their values, finding coping strategies, asking for help, changing careers/jobs, negotiating benefits/pay, finding worth in other places, and creating healthy routines.

It 1000000 percent is a structural issue. I use the term systemic but yes you are correct. All work is stressful and has cons but when there are these systemic issues at play that is where the burnout happens. It is when we are not valued at work, not given freedom or opportunity, no opportuntiies for growth, not having boundaries respected, etc.

Like a lot of things, even though we are not the cause, the recovery ends up on the individual.

Once They Were Pets. Now Giant Goldfish Are Menacing the Great Lakes.

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/08/science/goldfish-invasive-great-lakes.html

Inside a fishbowl, the goldfish — a species of carp native to East Asia, bred for aesthetic delight and traditionally believed to bring good fortune — is hardly more than home décor. Usually just a few inches long, it is among the easiest of pets to keep.

But released into the wild, the seemingly humble goldfish, freed from glass boundaries and no longer limited to meager meals of flakes, can grow to monstrous proportions. They can even kill off native marine wildlife and help destroy fragile and economically valuable ecosystems.

“They can eat anything and everything,” said Christine Boston, an aquatic research biologist with Fisheries and Oceans Canada.

How millennials learned to dread motherhood

https://www.vox.com/features/23979357/millennials-motherhood-dread-parenting-birthrate-women-policy

Should we stumble across moms on Instagram, Facebook, or TikTok who do seem to be enjoying the experience of child-rearing, we’re taught to be very, very suspicious. Assume they’re “pitchwomen.” Assume they’re ridiculously wealthy. Assume, as Times columnist Jessica Grose put it, that they’re mostly peddling “pernicious expectations.”

Like so many women, I fervently consume this content, wanting both to set realistic expectations for myself and to learn in solidarity with those who are already moms.

College-educated millennial women considering motherhood — and a growing number from Gen Z too — are now so well-versed in the statistics of modern maternal inequity that we can recite them as if we’d already experienced them ourselves. We can speak authoritatively about the burden of “the mental load” in heterosexual relationships, the chilling costs of child care, the staggering maternal mortality rates for Black women. We can tell you that women spend twice as much time as men on average doing household chores after kids enter the picture, that marriages with kids tend to suffer. We’re so informed, frankly, that we find ourselves feeling less like empowered adults than like grimacing fortune-tellers peering into a crystal ball.

Previous generations “did not experience the same vocal outward world that we’re living in today where everybody is telling you it’s almost crazy for you to have children,” said Sherisa de Groot, founder of Raising Mothers, a literary group focused on parents of color. “That it’s selfish for you to have children. That it’s almost, like, a morally wrong thing to do at this point, because look at the hell basket we’re living in.”

Taylor Swift Democrats: Conservatives are losing the "don't be weirdos" contest

https://www.richardhanania.com/p/taylor-swift-democrats

What many analysts seem not to understand is that most people are paying a lot less attention to politics than they are. If you’re the type who closely follows right-wing media, you will see that Twitter and Fox News provide a nonstop stream of profiles of liberal weirdos. You see the 6’5 man with the receding hairline dominating girls basketball or whatever, and think why can’t everyone else realize how insane liberals have become? Yet, I think for your average voter who’s not paying attention, they’re not necessarily noticing the craziest leftists and connecting them to the Democratic Party. Or maybe they are, but the connection is a lot less clear than the association that Republicans have with their worst elements.

The Elite's War on Remote Work Has Nothing to Do with Productivity

https://www.okdoomer.io/heres-why-they-want-you-back-at-the-office-so-bad/

Before the pandemic, the internet was filled with stories about the evils of office work. It was bad for your productivity. It was bad for your creativity. It was bad for your health. They were trying to sell us treadmill desks.

Remember all that?

Now everything has changed. If you work from home, apparently you're a lazy bum who wastes company time by snacking, playing video games, watching Netflix, shopping, hanging out with your friends, drinking, spending time with your family, or having sex. You're an awful person.

How dare you cook a healthy lunch at home. How dare you go for a walk in the middle of the day to clear your head. How dare you take a short nap to regain your focus. Didn't you know that an epic commute is actually good for your mental health? Sitting in a cubicle is great for your heart.

So, what's really going on here?

It’s about real estate.

Decarbonization: Stocks and flows, abundance and scarcity, net zero

https://www.nathanielbullard.com/presentations

My annual presentation on the state of decarbonization told with climate, capital markets, technology, and sector data. A coherent view of the future begins with the clearest possible view of the present. 

Cause, Effect, and the Structure of the Social World

https://www.bu.edu/bulawreview/files/2023/12/STEVENSON.pdf

This Article is built around a central empirical claim: most reforms and interventions in the criminal legal space are shown to have little lasting effect when evaluated with gold standard methods. While this might be disappointing from the perspective of someone hoping to learn what levers to pull to achieve change, I argue that this teaches us something valuable about the structure of the social world. When it comes to the type of limited-scope interventions that lend themselves to high-quality evaluation, social change is hard to engineer. Stabilizing forces push people back toward the path they would have been on absent the intervention. Cascades—small interventions that lead to large and lasting changes—are rare. And causal processes are complex and context dependent, meaning that a success achieved in one setting may not port well to another.

This has a variety of implications. It suggests that a dominant perspective on social change—one that forms a pervasive background for academic research and policymaking—is at least partially a myth. Understanding this shifts how we should think about social change and raises important questions about the process of knowledge generation.

How bad are search results? Let's compare Google, Bing, Marginalia, Kagi, Mwmbl, and ChatGPT

https://danluu.com/seo-spam/

More generally, most tech folks I'm connected to seem to think that Google search results are significantly worse than they were ten years ago (Mastodon poll, Twitter poll, Threads poll). However, there's a sizable group of vocal folks who claim that search results are still great. E.g., a bluesky thought leader who gets high engagement says:

i think the rending of garments about how even google search is terrible now is pretty overblown1

I suspect what's going on here is that some people have gotten so used working around bad software that they don't even know they're doing it, reflexively doing the modern equivalent of hitting ctrl+s all the time in editors, or ctrl+a; ctrl+c when composing anything in a text box. Every adept user of the modern web has a bag of tricks they use to get decent results from queries. From having watched quite a few users interact with computers, that doesn't appear to be normal, even among people who are quite competent in various technical fields, e.g., mechanical engineering2. However, it could be that people who are complaining about bad search result quality are just hopping on the "everything sucks" bandwagon and making totally unsubstantiated comments about search quality.

How to Be a Policy Entrepreneur in the American Vetocracy


In our highly polarized political environment, five structural factors originally intended as checks and balances have metastasized into what Francis Fukuyama calls a “vetocracy”: bicameralism, the Senate fili­buster, presidentialism, adversarial legalism, and federalism. To be sure, these institutions also have benefits, such as guarding against the tyranny of the majority. But to actually change laws, policy entrepreneurs must design their solutions to run this gauntlet of veto points. It may be difficult, but it is possible to build state capacity while operating within the constraints of U.S. institutions: the federal government can use carrots and sticks to align state and local policy with its goals; Congress can use its authority to limit judicial review; and legislators can add riders to must-pass legislation.

Sam Altman, Freed

To explain, OpenAI as you know it is actually three companies, and its mission is, and I quote, to “create a safe AGI that is broadly beneficial,” which can refer to everything from a totally sentient artificial intelligence to, per Sam Altman, the “equivalent of a median human that you could hire as a co-worker.” OpenAI, Inc. is a 501(c)(3) Public Charity — a non-profit that owns and controls the managing entity, OpenAI GP LLC, which controls the holding company for the OpenAI nonprofit entity, which is the majority owner of OpenAI Global, LLC, which is the “capped” for-profit entity. It is the bizarre result of OpenAI’s 2019 move to a “capped” for-profit model — though one shouldn’t give them any credit, as investors are capped at one hundred times their initial investment.

While this may seem confusing, the ultimate result is that OpenAI is controlled at its heart not by its investors, but by a board of directors that doesn’t hold any equity
Sidenote: Currently, some in the valley are complaining about OpenAI’s board being “inexperienced,” as if tech’s boards of directors have traditionally done a good job. The same board that fired Steve Jobs was filled with prominent venture capitalists and executives, as was the board of WeWork, Theranos (which included military leaders and former secretaries of state), and Juicero. Jawbone, a company that went from a $3bn valuation to bankruptcy, had industry figureheads like Ben Horowitz, and doomed entertainment startup Quibi had the CEO of Condé Nast and the founding partner of top entertainment law firm Ziffren Brittenham LLP. In fact, I’d argue that the boards of major tech firms have overwhelmingly failed to police their companies, rarely, if ever, taking action against executives behaving badly.